Here's a quandry, who the hell is buying a Mr. Goodbar in this situation? That schmuck really needs to assess their decision making abilities, because when you break it down its really a simple choice.
Both start with the same classic Hershey's milk chocolate base, but they take wildly divergent paths from here, one mixed with solid, but ultimately forgettable peanuts, the other inspiration-ally paired with delectable almonds. But if that's not convincing enough, continue on.
Put yourself in this scenario: You're in a bar there are two bowls of nuts in front of you, both unsalted, plain as can be. One jar is peanuts, the other is almonds. You're choosing the almonds. I refuse to accept any other answer in this situation.
Sure, salted peanuts would clobber salted almonds, its no contest. But you know what, salted peanuts and chocolate would taste like dick, so the point is moot.
So there's your verdict, nothing against Mr. Goodbar personally, you've simply been outclassed by your far superior cousin.
By the way there is a poll to the right, feel free to vote for your favorite out of the two, just know that at the end of the day I'll be announcing Hershey's with Almonds the winner regardless of the tally. Yea, this here is a dictatorship and I reign supreme. Poll is on the upper right.